Mindfully Gay Podcast

What Is A Good Gay? (Epi 37)

John Cottrell & Jerry Buie Season 1 Episode 37

Send us a text

🎙️ Mindfully Gay Podcast -- Episode Title: "What Is A Good Gay?"

Air Date: Friday, June 20, 2025

What does it really mean to be a "good gay"?

In this powerful new episode of the Mindfully Gay Podcast, John and Jerry wrestle with this loaded question--one that emerged during a retreat Jerry hosted with queer men from a wide range of backgrounds, cultures, and generations. Inspired by their honest, soul-searching conversations, the hosts bring this provocative topic to the table.

Together, they explore how the idea of a "good gay" is shaped by social expectations, cultural conditioning, and even internalized stereotypes within the LGBTQ+ community. They dive into the impact of heteronormative behavior, gay panic, and the pressure to "perform" a certain kind of gayness--whether that means being fabulous, fit, politically active, masculine, or palatable to others.

From identity policing to the perpetuation of harmful tropes, Jerry and John examine how the queer community sometimes mirrors the very norms it seeks to challenge. They don't promise easy answers--but they do open a space for honest reflection, thoughtful questions, and new possibilities for what queer authenticity could look like.

🔊 Listen to the full audio episode on [Apple Podcasts](https://podcasts.apple.com) or [Spotify](https://spotify.com)

📺 Watch the full video episode on YouTube at [Mindfully Gay Podcast](https://youtube.com/@MindfullyGayPodcast)

💬 After you listen, we'd love to hear from you: How would YOU answer the question -- "What is a good gay?"

🗓️ New episodes drop every Friday. Be sure to subscribe on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or YouTube so you never miss a conversation.

@mindfully_gay (Instagram)